Every Black Friday, the same numbers dominate the headlines: record sales, transaction volumes and year-on-year growth. For brands, a strong weekend can look like an obvious success.
But headline revenue only tells us how much consumers bought. It doesn’t tell us whether those purchases would have happened anyway.
A customer buying a new coffee machine on Black Friday might represent additional demand. But if they were already planning to buy it as a Christmas present in December, the brand may simply have brought the same purchase forward, potentially at a lower margin.
That leaves brands with a more important question: how much profitable, incremental demand did Black Friday actually create?
Measure incrementality, not just Black Friday revenue
Rather than comparing Black Friday revenue and unit volume with the previous year in isolation, brands should measure performance across the wider trading period, from November to mid-January, using October as a pre-promotional baseline.
For brands selling on Amazon, Amazon Marketing Cloud (AMC) can help identify whether promotional buyers were new to the brand and whether they returned in December or January.
Brands selling across Amazon and their own D2C sites should go a step further. Clean-room analysis can help establish whether Amazon promotions are reaching new customers or simply pulling existing customers away from the brand’s own site. A strong Amazon result looks very different if overall sales across the two channels barely change.
This gives brands a much stronger basis for separating genuinely incremental sales from revenue that has simply moved between dates or channels.
Discount by product, not across the range
Brands should also use Black Friday performance to understand which discounts actually drove sales.
Not every product needs the same offer. If one Stock Keeping Unit (SKU) requires a significant reduction to move while another performs strongly with a modest discount, discounting both by the same amount risks giving away margin unnecessarily.
Looking at performance product by product can help brands pinpoint where discounts are really making a difference. Which SKUs responded to smaller discounts? Which only moved with aggressive promotions? And where did going deeper make little difference? The aim should be to find the minimum effective discount for each product, rather than assuming a deeper deal automatically produces a better result.
Timing matters too. Europe’s lowest-30-day-price rule means brands need to think carefully about when promotions go live, as an earlier discount can affect how a later Black Friday offer is presented. Brands therefore need to plan offers across the season, ensuring their strongest promotions are timed to make the most of peak traffic
Turn deal-driven customers into repeat customers
The next challenge is turning customers acquired during Black Friday into customers who return when the deals are over.
For products suited to repeat purchase, Subscribe & Save can help turn a discounted first purchase into recurring demand. Over time, that can make brands less dependent on promotional events to generate volume. The goal is for Black Friday to attract new customers who go on to buy again, rather than simply shifting existing demand to lower-margin sales and causing a drop-off afterwards.
Brands should therefore track how many promotional customers buy again, how quickly they return and whether those purchases continue once prices return to normal. If customers only appear when a major discount is available, the promotion may have driven a transaction without building much longer-term value.
Plan December spend before Black Friday starts
The opportunity doesn’t end with Cyber Monday, so neither should the plan. Brands should set their December advertising budgets before Black Friday begins, identifying which products they want to continue supporting and establishing clear return-on-ad-spend floors.
That matters because December remains competitive, with click costs often rising as gifting peaks ahead of delivery cut-offs. Gifting lines that continue to convert profitably may warrant further investment through December, while other products may no longer justify the same level of spend once promotional pricing ends.
Having those thresholds in place makes it easier to protect budget for gifting lines and other products performing efficiently, while pulling back where higher advertising costs or discounting are eating into the value of each sale.
Make Black Friday a growth strategy
Black Friday and Cyber Monday remain major commercial opportunities, but the immediate sales spike shouldn’t be the ultimate measure of success.
The value of Black Friday should extend beyond the revenue generated during the event. Used well, it can give brands the evidence to make better decisions about pricing, acquisition, retention and advertising throughout the year.
It can also put brands in a stronger position ahead of the next promotional period, with a clearer view of where discounting genuinely creates value and where it simply gives margin away.
The brands that get Black Friday right won’t simply be those that sell the most over one weekend. They’ll be the ones that use it to build profitable demand that lasts beyond the deals.







Share