Argos laptop refund ruling: what it means for online returns


Argos laptop refund ruling: what it means for online returns

The Court of Appeal has ruled that a customer who switched on a laptop bought online, activating its preinstalled Windows 11 software, kept the right to cancel the order and get a refund.

The judgment in Adodo v Argos Ltd was handed down on 13 November 2026.

What happened in Adodo v Argos?

Dr Ebenezer Adodo ordered a £379 Lenovo laptop on the Argos website in August 2024 and collected it the same day through click and collect at a Sainsbury’s store.

He switched it on to check it worked with the software he used for his work at Leicester University, found compatibility problems and took it back on 5 September. Argos refused a refund because the box had been opened and the laptop turned on.

Argos argued that activating Windows 11 broke a “digital seal”, which brought the sale under the exception in the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 for sealed computer software unsealed after delivery.

What did the Court of Appeal decide?

Lady Justice Andrews, with Lady Justice King and Lord Justice Foxton agreeing, said the exception must be read strictly and narrowly. It covers contracts where the recording or software is itself the item being bought and is physically sealed in packaging, not a computer supplied with its operating system preloaded.

The court noted that shoppers can try out laptops in a shop. Under the Regulations, a retailer can instead charge for any loss in value caused by handling beyond what is needed to check the goods, but Argos made no attempt to show any such cost.

Does click and collect count as a distance sale?

Yes. The court agreed with the earlier finding that an online order collected in store is a distance contract covered by the Regulations.

Argos was ordered to refund the price of the laptop, with interest from 14 days after the attempted return. Dr Adodo, who represented himself, brought the claim in Leicester County Court as a small claim.

What this means for online retailers

  • Devices with preloaded software: switching one on to test it does not, on this ruling, end the customer’s right to cancel.
  • Click and collect: orders placed online and collected in store carry the same cancellation rights as home delivery.
  • Excessive handling: the route the court pointed to is a deduction for loss in value, which the retailer has to be able to show.

Returns policies that refuse refunds on opened or switched-on electronics bought online may be worth a second look.

Related stories:
Record number of retailers will charge for returns this peak
Half of retailers write off up to 40 per cent of returned stock
CMA delivery fees rules: mandatory charges must be in the total price

Share

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp

Related News


Sign up to receive our newsletter